Adani Group, SEBI and the Report of Hindenburg Research

On 10th August 2024, Saturday, the Hindenburg Research published a so-called explosive report on the Security and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) chairman Madhabi Puri Buch and Indian conglomerate Adani Group. The report made an allegation that the SEBI chairman’s involvement in offshore funds and money siphoning. This report neither did generate the kind of discussion nor have the same reactions from the stock market the way a similar report in January 2023 had on the Indian stock market and Adani Group stocks!

This time, the Adani Group as whole has lost its market capitalization by just about 1% than the market capitalization before the said report, released on 10th August 2024! However, a similar report by Hindenburg Research in January 2023 wiped out the value of some Adani Group companies by 83%. Adani Total Power lost about 83% of market capitalization post revelations in January 2024. The whole Adani group had come under huge pressure. The whole group lost about $150 billion in valuation. Many financial institutions raised concerns about the future of Adani Group. It also had to cancel its FPO. Gautam Adani, the group chairman of the India conglomerate lost its position from the list of top ten richest people in the world!

Why? Has the short seller Hindenburg lost credibility at least in the Indian security market? A short answer to this question is perhaps, yes!

Reliance Industries has Got the US Nod to Import Crude Oil from Venezuela

Reliance Industries has got the US nod to import crude oil from Venezuela. ONGC has also applied for a waiver to buy crude oil from Venezuela! It is quite possible that ONGC will also get a similar nod. It should be noted that Reliance Industries is the second largest buyer of crude oil from Venezuela.

This decision of the USA will increase India's access to cheap crude oil. I am sure that India's strong relationship with Russia, increasing share of Russian crude oil in Indian basket and the recent visit of Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to Russia which was widely circulated in the world media by the Russian state media must have played a significant role in this decision. The US wants India to cut its crude oil import from Russia. So India must have argued that until and unless India has access to other cheap alternatives, how could India cut its crude oil imports from Russia? The US must have agreed and nodded to the application of Reliance Industries for waiver to enable India to explore more and perhaps better alternatives than Russia. It must be noted that the US had imposed sanctions in 2019. This was the time when India’s crude oil import from Russia started increasing which had increased to 40% of the total Indian crude oil basket!

Union Budget 2024 Aimed at Demographic Dividends

It has been 10 years since the government gave any tax relief to the middle class! It was expected that the Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman would be increasing the tax deduction limit under 80C of Income Tax Act from ₹2.5 lakhs to ₹4 lakhs or ₹5 lakhs along with standard deduction in the first Budget of Modi 3.0 with the purpose to increase the demand in the Indian economy which would lead to more jobs because of increased disposable income. However, the budget is not that generous as far as the deduction is concerned. I, along with other economists, was sure and still am that if only the standard deduction limit is increased, then it would not be able to achieve the dual goals of increasing economic activities in the economy as well as controlling the falling savings in the economy.

Why has the GST Collection Data for June 2024 not been Released?

On 1st July 2024, India completed 7 years of implementation of GST in the Indian economy. Initially it was a roller coaster ride with many states objecting on various issues along with implementation confusions and glitches. As a result many had expected it to fail but India has implemented GST smoothly across the nation. It is a great achievement as it has unified the Indian markets as far as taxation is concerned.

However, some concerns are being raised with July moving towards August! Every month in the first week, India has been regularly and religiously releasing the GST collection data. It was religiously followed till June 2024. But since 1st June 2024, GST collection data has not been released. None knows, why has it not been released?

People are now speculating about it with so many conspiracy theories. However, media reports suggest that the GST collection in the month of June 2024 was ₹1.74 lakh crores which is 7.7% greater than the collection of June 2023.

The Fall in the Share of the Households in the Capital Formation in India

Post pandemic, the share of the households in the capital formation in the Indian economy is falling. Household savings had increased increased significantly during the pandemic because of increased risk aversion of the citizens. The households post pandemic have used the savings and heavily borrowed to buy different classes of assets resulting in a fall in the household savings to 61% in financial year 2023 from 78% in financial year 2021. However, it should also be noted that the household financial liabilities in India had increased to 5.8% of the GDP which is highest since financial year 2012.

The fall in the share of the households in the capital formation is a cause of concern for any economy. For a developing economy like India with a share of more than 70% of the population below age of 25 years, it is even more worrisome. It would have a multifaceted impact on the overall well-being for the economy and the citizens.

The fall in the share of the households in the capital formation in Indian economy would lead to many problems like higher inequality in income as well as wealth, fall in consumption, slowdown in housing market, lower wealth accumulation and bad savings and financial health of the citizens in medium to long term which at present when inequality is at very high level in country.

Peculiar Case of Inflation in India

Someone asked me why do most of the non-BJP ruled states have higher fuel prices than that of BJP ruled states? Don't they realize that it'll be the reason for high general prices?

First of all, I wanted to ignore this question due to its political reason but after a while I decided to respond knowing the fact that the answer to this question is very peculiar. If I try to remain politically correct, there would not be a factual and satisfying answer to this question. It is not possible at all to be politically correct and answer this question both at the same time!

As a matter of fact, most of the non-BJP ruled states are charging higher VAT on petroleum products than the BJP ruled states. As a result, the oil prices are higher in Non-BJP ruled states. But it is not that simple. It is more complex than it looks at face.

Pesticide Use in India and the World

The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations has published a report with a title of “Pesticides Use, Pesticides Trade and Pesticides Indicators; Global, Regional and Country trends, 1990–2020”. This report is providing some very important insight about the global agricultural practices. The information is to some extent very surprising and frightful.

The following graph represents the pesticides Kilogram /Hectare used in different countries in agricultural activities.

Relationship of India with the UAE

In geopolitics and foreign policy making, things are often very long term, move slowly and look very deceptive and sometimes illusive also. From outside they often seem to move in the north direction but actually they lead in the south direction or might be in the east or west. It can be anything.

From the way the world perceives India today, it is very clear that India is doing well in the foreign policy making and positioning and placing its bets and people.

Relationship of India with most of the nations across the globe is improving dramatically. This is also true in the case of the United Arab Emirates (UAE). The relationship of India with the UAE has never been so strong the way it looks today and it is becoming stronger day by day. None could have even thought of it 10-15 years back but Modi Government has done wonders in the last ten years to completely change it by serving and securing the economic interest of UAE.

UPI vs. NEFT vs. IMPS: Which is Preferred?

India has many ways to transfer money supported by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and National Payment Corporation of India (NPCI) using banking platforms, BHIM app, payment banks as well as payment wallets. These methods are Unified Payment Interface (UPI), Real Time Gross Settlement (RTGS), National Electronic Funds Transfer (NEFT), Immediate Payment Service (IMPS), Electronic Clearing System (ECS), Mobile Wallets, Prepaid Cards, Debit Cards, Credit Cards, Unstructured Supplementary Service Data (USSD), and AADHAAR Enabled Payment System (APES). At present, of all these ways, three ways of payment have turned out to be the most popular and those are UPI, NEFT and IMPS.

Visa Free Entry to Indians is Increasing

Rising economic might of India is increasing the importance of India in the global economy. It should be noted that the Indian economy is the fastest growing large economy in the world and is expected to become the third largest economy in the world by 2030 and probably a $5 trillion economy by the end of 2028 itself.

This simple but very important fact is forcing the countries of the world to review their overall public and economic policies in the matter of India to fit in the new reality. They are adjusting their policies at every level irrespective of the political spectrum.

India Needs to Increase Investment in Agriculture

According to The World Bank, 60% of the total land in India was found to be suitable for agriculture in 2021 against the world average of 38.4%. However, the share of cultivated land was only 53.7% of the total land in India of which 50.4% is arable and 3.3% is covered permanent crops, 24.4% of total land area is forest land and rest is used for other different purposes.

As per the definition given by Food and Agriculture Organization of United Nations (FAO), agricultural land covers only 38.4% of the world’s land area in 2011. However, only 10.9% of the global land area is arable that can be used for growing crops and just 1.2% of global land area is covered by permanent crops.

Micro ATMs are Helping Fill the Gaps

Financial inclusion has been a multifaceted problem for the whole world. The whole world is facing difficulties bringing in people in the formal financial system. Even the developed countries cannot claim to have brought its citizens into the formal financial system. And when it comes to a developing country like India, financial inclusion is a herculean task. However, India’s performance in bringing her citizens into the formal financial system in the last decade is really remarkable.

A number of initiatives and schemes such as Jan Dhan Yojana to Pension Yojana to Mudra Yojana etc. have been started by the central government in India over time to bring in people in the formal financial network but still a long distance is yet to be covered. There are crores of individuals who are still not part of the formal financial system or cannot access the formal financial system. Though, the government has been trying to use every possible initiative and technological advancement to advance financial inclusion in India. ATMs have also been used to increase financial inclusion in India especially in rural India.

Credit Cards are Becoming More Popular in India

Anything and everything has some direct or indirect impact on people and their behaviours and responses. Globalisation, technological advancements, innovations and the different practices in different parts of the world have together completely changed the markets and so the consumers’ behaviours. These have brought in significant change in the financial behaviours of the consumers also and India is not an exception to this phenomenon. Rather India has been a pioneer in many changes these days especially after 2010.

All types of loan products were traditionally considered to be the last option and if possible were expected to avoid loan products as much as possible and financial institutions were always the last assort for the people. However, there is a significant change in the financial behaviour of Indian consumers over the last decade.

Minimum Support Price (MSP) is a Necessity

Minimum Support Price (MSP) of farm produce has always been a controversial issue as higher MSP always meant higher cost of living for the salaried class and so higher inflation for them! And when urbanization in India has become more prominent than ever, high MSP becomes a political issue rather than being just an economic matter. And over time, MSP which was brought in the Indian economic policy making has become completely a political issue and its economic importance has been pushed in political background!

But the question remains unanswered as to why India needs a regime of MSP when it is a very politically, socially as well as economically sensitive issue?

Rising Wealth Inequality in India

Inequalities in wealth and income are prevalent across the globe. There is perhaps no economy in the world that is not facing the challenges relating to inequalities in varying degrees. India is also faced with the challenge of increasing inequalities across states and regions on both fronts. Every year, through many surveys, different institutions and organizations highlight the issue of inequalities in India. A lot has been done to alleviate poetry but when it comes to inequalities, policy responses fail to address them.

After having a look at the data relating to wealth per adult in India, it is evident that the average wealth in India is found to be far higher than that of the median wealth. In 2022, the average wealth per adult was $18,048 and the median wealth was $4,107 in the same year. The average wealth was about four and a half times the median wealth in 2022.

Indian Economy a Bright Spot but a Bumpy Ride

Most of the economic indicators clearly and reasonably indicate that the Indian economy will grow with a growth rate of not less than 6% in 2023. This is the highest rate of growth among the largest economies in the world while the global economy is slowing down. So without a doubt, it can be said that the Indian economy is a bright spot in the global economy when a soft to moderate recession is in offing in the world economy. This may look euphoric but this ride wouldn’t be an easy one but bumpy and full of many challenges.

At present the Indian economy is facing two big problems that need to be fixed in the short to medium term. The first and most significant problem is high inflation in the economy. This is a very costly situation for the Indian economy. To tame the inflationary situation, RBI has maintained a hawkish monetary policy and this policy stance is the biggest challenge for the economy as if the central bank continues to increase the interest rates in the economy, it would be very costly for the economy.

Adani, Valuation and Share Prices

Post Hindenburg’s report, a kind of saga unfolded causing temporary chaos in the Indian security market and raising large numbers of questions relating to Adani Group ranging from financial reporting to stock price manipulations to corporate governance. But it becomes pertinent to ask whether those questions are relevant or not.

It is not that the Adani Group is beyond question. There are a large number of serious questions that should be asked and are being asked as well. However, a lot of people have suddenly woken up to ask questions relating to the valuations of the Adani Group stocks post-Hindenburg saga and the withdrawal of FPO by Adani Enterprises.

Adani Group: What has Changed?

Adani FPO has now been oversubscribed by 1.12 times amid huge chaos created by Hindenburg's report on Adani Group and doubts about the success of the FPO. From the data available about the subscribers, it is crystal clear that the non-institutional investors including family offices of wealthy families along with anchor investors have played an important role in the success of FPO.

As far as the subscribers’ interest in the FPO was concerned, for two days, there was hardly any taker of the FPO in the retail and NII segment. However, the investment from Abu Dhabi-based International Holding Company (IHC) worth $400 million in the FPO completely changed the environment and the prices of Adani Group companies not only stopped falling but some shares witnessed an increase.

Hindenburg’s Report on Adani and Its Ramifications

Hindenburg Research has come up with a report on the Adani Group which clearly alleges that the Adani Group firms have been involved in financial window dressing and stock market manipulations. These are very serious allegations with huge consequences and repercussions for the Adani Group in particular and the Indian economy in general. The shares of the Adani Group companies are on free fall since the report has gone public. Not only this but the report has also negatively affected the sentiments and volatility in the Indian stock market and many other stocks have to bear the brunt as a result of negative sentiments in the market.

Increasing Intellectual Bankruptcy in India

With the decision of the Supreme Court of India, all the questions regarding the constitutionality of the demonetisation of currency notes by the Indian government in 2016 are now settled forever. A 4:1 verdict establishes that due process was followed and the Reserve Bank of India was in the loop. However, the questions regarding the economic and social impact of demonetisation would never die down and should not. A fair and unbiased discussion, as well as an assessment of this key but knee-jerk policy decision, is necessary so that this episode of demonetisation could be used as a case study for future policymakers.

The Government of India demonetised ₹500 and ₹1,000 currency notes in 2016 with the stated objectives to clean illicit money and cashless economy which eventually proved to be a very costly affair for the economy. However, after six years of demonetisation, it can easily be said that ideally none of the stated objectives was ever achieved apart from the cleansing of the counterfeit currency notes from the market.